Wallington Deli

Nestled in the heart of Wallington, New Jersey, Wallington Deli stands out as a beloved local gem for deli enthusiasts craving authentic Italian-American flavors crafted with passion and precision. At 181 Paterson Ave, this deli offers more than just a quick bite—it’s a destination for food lovers seeking sandwiches and hot dishes that echo traditional recipes with a contemporary twist.

Wallington Deli’s menu is a celebration of classic deli delights, each item bursting with carefully balanced flavors and fresh ingredients. Signature dishes such as the Chicken Parmigiana with Vodka Sauce and the Drunken Chicken Parm Sandwich exemplify the kitchen’s commitment to bold, comforting tastes. The vodka sauce is silky and rich, enveloping the tender chicken cutlet with a perfect balance of tang and creaminess, while the freshly baked bread—praised repeatedly by loyal customers—adds a foundational texture that's both soft and robust. The Meatball Parm and Ham Salami and Cheese sandwiches are equally stellar, loaded with savory layers that satisfy every bite.

For those who enjoy a bit of adventurous flavor, the 2 Cutler Roasted Peppers with Fresh Mozzarella and Balsamic Glaze Sandwich offers a delightful contrast of sweet, smoky peppers with smooth mozzarella, accented by the tangy glaze. Meanwhile, the Philly Cheesesteak with Mozzarella pays homage to a classic, but with Wallington Deli’s signature freshness and care that sets it apart. Side options like Arancini and crispy Buffalo Wings with French Fries perfectly complement the main dishes, rounding out a meal that feels both hearty and satisfying.

Diners seeking lighter fare will appreciate the Greek Salad and Wrap Platter, which offer fresh, vibrant flavors balanced with a wholesome touch. The deli also excels in traditional pasta dishes like Chicken Parm over Penne or Spaghetti and Zitti with Vodka Sauce, offering affordable options packed with rich, comforting sauce and perfectly cooked pasta. And to satisfy a sweet tooth, homemade desserts like Tiramisu and Rice Pudding deliver just the right sweetness to end your meal on a high note.

More than just great food, Wallington Deli is known for its warm, attentive service. Customers consistently highlight the genuine care Paul and his staff put into every order—making sure every sandwich is made to perfection and every detail is just right. One reviewer, Richard Laurenzano, shares that while you might have to wait a little longer because "great food takes time to prepare," the quality and accuracy of each order make it well worth the brief pause.

What truly sets Wallington Deli apart is their in-house baked bread, a feature repeatedly praised by locals and visitors alike. Freshly made daily, it transforms every sandwich into an unforgettable experience—providing the perfect balance of softness to cradle the fillings and just the right crust for satisfying texture. This dedication to homemade quality, paired with classic, bold flavors, ensures that every sandwich truly lives up to their bold claim: The Best Sandwich in Town.

Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch, picking up an order for a special event, or craving a comforting dinner, Wallington Deli offers an authentic, flavorful experience infused with the heart and soul of Italian deli tradition. It’s a place where passion for food meets genuine hospitality, making every visit not just a meal, but a cherished culinary moment.

Contact Information:
181 Paterson Ave, Wallington, NJ 07057, United States
Phone: +1 973-472-6525